Greatest Cricket Moments

Billy Midwinter's 5/78 — Australia's First Test Five-for, March 1877

1877-03-16Australia vs EnglandFirst Test, Melbourne, 15-19 March 18772 min readSeverity: Mild

Summary

Billy Midwinter, the Gloucestershire-born Australian all-rounder, took 5 for 78 in England's first innings of the inaugural Test at Melbourne — the first five-wicket haul in Test cricket. He went on to become the only man to play Test cricket for both England and Australia.

Background

Midwinter was a Gloucestershire native who had emigrated to Bendigo as a child. By 1877 he was playing for Victoria and was Gloucestershire's overseas pro in the English summer.

Build-Up

England, replying to Australia's 245, were 109/4 when Midwinter came on. He bowled long, accurate spells from the southern end through the rest of the innings.

What Happened

Midwinter was 26, born in St Briavels, Gloucestershire, and emigrated to Australia as a boy. A tall, strong, round-arm medium-pacer who batted usefully in the lower middle order, he was picked for the All-Australian XI in March 1877 alongside the Sydney professionals. Bowling tirelessly through the long English first innings, he took the wickets of Selby, Charlwood, Armitage, Lillywhite and Hill to finish with 5/78 in 54 four-ball overs. It was the first five-wicket haul in Test cricket. Midwinter scored 5 and 17 with the bat. The most extraordinary part of his career was still to come: in 1878 he toured England with the Australian XI, in 1881-82 he played for England against Australia in Australia, and over his career he represented Australia in eight Tests and England in four. No other cricketer has played Tests for both countries.

Key Moments

1

Midwinter dismisses Selby for 7

2

Removes Charlwood, Armitage and Lillywhite in succession

3

Bowls Hill to finish with 5/78

4

First five-wicket haul in Test cricket

Timeline

1851

William Evans Midwinter born in Gloucestershire

1860s

Family emigrates to Bendigo, Victoria

Mar 1877

Takes 5/78 in first Test

1881-82

Plays for England against Australia, in Australia

1890

Dies in Melbourne asylum, aged 39

Notable Quotes

Midwinter was the strongest man on either side; he could bowl all day.

Tom Horan, on his Victoria team-mate

Aftermath

Midwinter played in the second Test at Melbourne and on the 1878 tour of England, then was famously 'kidnapped' by W.G. Grace at Lord's in June 1878 to play for Gloucestershire instead of the Australians at Surrey. He represented England on the 1881-82 tour of Australia before returning to the Australian side.

⚖️ The Verdict

The first five-wicket Test innings haul, taken by the only man ever to play Tests for both England and Australia.

Legacy & Impact

Midwinter's dual-nationality Test career is unique. His mental health collapsed in the late 1880s after the deaths of his wife and children; he died in a Melbourne asylum in 1890, aged 39. He was inducted into the Australian Cricket Hall of Fame in 2011.

Frequently Asked Questions

Did he really play for both Australia and England?
Yes — eight Tests for Australia, four for England. He remains the only cricketer to have done so.
What was the 'kidnap' at Lord's?
In June 1878 W.G. Grace and a Gloucestershire colleague went to Lord's and persuaded Midwinter to leave the Australian team's match at the Oval and play for Gloucestershire instead. The incident caused a serious diplomatic row.

Related Incidents

Mild

Middlesex County Cricket Club Founded — Cricket Comes Home to Lord's, 1864

Middlesex cricket establishment

1864-02-02

Middlesex County Cricket Club was founded on 2 February 1864 at a meeting in London, the same year in which the MCC legalised overarm bowling and John Wisden published his first Almanack. It was one of several county clubs formally constituted in the busy years of 1863–65 as English cricket reorganised itself around a county structure that would eventually evolve into a formal championship.

#overarm-era#early-county-cricket#1860s
Mild

Lancashire County Cricket Club Founded — Manchester's Game Gets Organised, 1864

Lancashire cricket establishment

1864-01-12

Lancashire County Cricket Club was formally constituted at a meeting in Manchester on 12 January 1864, giving England's most cricket-passionate industrial county a formal organisational structure to match the grassroots enthusiasm that had been filling grounds at Old Trafford and elsewhere for decades. Lancashire, alongside Yorkshire, represented the great northern cricket public that William Clarke's All-England Eleven had first mobilised commercially in the 1840s.

#overarm-era#early-county-cricket#1860s
Mild

V.E. Walker Takes All Ten — Every Wicket at Lord's, Middlesex v Lancashire, 1865

Middlesex vs Lancashire

1865-07-26

Vyell Edward Walker of Middlesex took all ten wickets in a Lancashire innings at Lord's on 26 July 1865 — one of the earliest documented instances of a bowler taking all ten in a first-class match. Walker, a medium-pace round-arm bowler who also captained Middlesex, achieved the feat without assistance from any other bowler, delivering one of the most complete individual bowling performances of the Victorian era.

#overarm-era#early-county-cricket#1860s